The fairest method is per-leg splitting: calculate the fuel cost for each leg (distance/MPG × gas price), then divide that leg’s cost by the number of passengers riding that leg. Each person only pays for the legs they were in the car. This prevents short-ride passengers from subsidizing long-ride ones.
- Calculate each leg’s cost: (distance / MPG) × gas price
- Divide each leg’s cost by number of passengers on that leg
- Sum each person’s share across all legs they rode
- Example: 150 miles at 28 MPG and $3.50/gal = $18.75 per leg
- With 3 passengers: $6.25 each for that leg
| Split Method | Fair When... | Unfair When... |
|---|---|---|
| Per-leg split | Passengers change per leg | Never—this is the gold standard |
| Even total split | Everyone rides every leg | People join/leave mid-trip |
| Per-mile share | Solo passengers on different routes | Everyone rides together |
| Driver exempt | Driver provides the car + maintenance | Driver chose a gas-guzzling vehicle |